Supreme Court Dismisses Slew of 2020 Presidential Election Lawsuits


The Supreme Court threw out a series of legal challenges on Feb. 22 to voting processes and results in several states left over from the recent presidential election cycle.

The high court didn’t explain why it refused to hear the cases, but three justices dissented from the decision not to hear one of the cases from Pennsylvania.

On Jan. 11, with Inauguration Day just over a week away, the high court denied requests from the litigants–President Donald Trump, Republicans, and Trump supporters—to expedite several of the lawsuits, which concerned the presidential elections held in the battleground states of Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. The court, as is its custom, didn’t explain why it dismissed the emergency applications seeking to fast-track the lawsuits.

President Joe Biden, a Democrat, was inaugurated on Jan. 20, alongside Vice President Kamala Harris after Congress voted Jan. 7 to reject objections by senators and representatives challenging Electoral College votes from disputed states won narrowly by Biden. That vote took place after a breach of the U.S. Capitol by hundreds of protesters delayed the certification process for hours.

Some of the lawsuits challenged the election results on the basis of allegedly unconstitutional changes made to state election procedures. Article II of the U.S. Constitution states that “Each State shall appoint [electors for president and vice president] in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct.” Litigants point out that the legislative power here is “plenary,” meaning unqualified and absolute.

State officials, they say, aren’t allowed to modify election procedures without the consent of the legislature.

One of the now-dismissed appeals, Republican Party of Pennsylvania v. Degraffenreid, court files 20-542 and 20-574, was originally known as Republican Party of Pennsylvania v. Boockvar, but then respondent Kathy Boockvar resigned as Pennsylvania’s secretary of state and was replaced by Veronica Degraffenreid. The case dealt with the perceived overreach of the state’s Supreme Court when it unilaterally changed election rules without the consent of the state legislature.

The GOP argued in its petition that “important questions of federal law [were] implicated by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s 4–3 decision extending the General Assembly’s Election Day received-by deadline and mandating a presumption of timeliness for non-postmarked ballots.”

This is the case in which Justice Samuel Alito ordered on Nov. 6, three days after Election Day, that “all ballots received by mail after 8:00 p.m. on November 3 be segregated,” away from other voted ballots.

Justices Alito, Clarence Thomas, and Neil Gorsuch dissented from the Supreme Court’s decision not to hear the appeal.

On Feb. 22, Alito wrote in his dissent, joined by Gorsuch, that the case presents “an important and recurring constitutional question: whether the Elections or Electors Clauses of the United States Constitution … are violated when a state court holds that a state constitutional provision overrides a state statute governing the manner in which a federal election is to be conducted. That question has divided the lower courts, and our review at this time would be greatly beneficial.”

In his dissent, Thomas expressed frustration, writing that the court “failed to settle this dispute before the election, and thus provide clear rules. Now we again fail to provide clear rules for future elections.”

Political News

Recent Articles

more articles
September 17, 2021
Brian Peskin Enhancing Your Body’s Ability to Fight the COVID 19 Virus with EFAs
Brian Peskin Enhancing Your Body’s Ability to Fight the COVID 19 Virus with EFAs

Brian Peskin Enhancing Your Body’s Ability to Fight the COVID 19 Virus with EFAs. EFA's have anti-fungal, anti-yeast, and anti-microbial properties, helping to protect against infections. Keeping bones strong.

September 12, 2021
England Drops Vaccine Passport Plan
England Drops Vaccine Passport Plan

The plan to mandate CCP (Chinese Communist Party) virus vaccine passports for n...

September 12, 2021
DeSantis Responds to Biden’s Vaccine Mandate: ‘In Florida, We Will Fight Back’
DeSantis Responds to Biden’s Vaccine Mandate: ‘In Florida, We Will Fight Back’

Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis said his state will fight back against President Joe ...

September 10, 2021
19 Governors, 2 AGs Resist Biden’s Vaccine Mandates
19 Governors, 2 AGs Resist Biden’s Vaccine Mandates

More than a dozen governors and two attorneys general late on Sept. 9 issued st...

September 2, 2021
Sweden Bans Travelers From Israel, One of the Most Vaccinated Nations
Sweden Bans Travelers From Israel, One of the Most Vaccinated Nations

Sweden became the second European Union country to ban Israeli residents from e...

Do you want to talk?

Drop us a line and we'll get back as soon as we can.

Upcoming Events

more events
Sep
21
Tue
Sep
22
Wed
Sep
23
Thu
Sep
24
Fri
Sep
25
Sat
Sep
26
Sun
Sep
27
Mon
Sep
28
Tue
Sep
29
Wed
Sep
30
Thu
Oct
01
Fri
Oct
02
Sat
Oct
03
Sun
Oct
04
Mon
Oct
05
Tue
Oct
06
Wed
Oct
07
Thu
Oct
08
Fri
Oct
09
Sat
Oct
10
Sun
Oct
11
Mon
Oct
12
Tue
Oct
13
Wed
Oct
14
Thu
Oct
15
Fri
Oct
16
Sat
Oct
17
Sun
Oct
18
Mon
Oct
19
Tue
Oct
20
Wed